Mapping the Participant Experience System

The Problem with One-Off Fixes

In sport and recreation, we often notice an outcome that we would like to change. Registration is down, participants are not returning, or attendance has become inconsistent. It’s natural to look for ways to address these concerns, and sometimes that means introducing a quick fix.

We might change a schedule, add an incentive, adjust a program, or introduce a new policy. These changes can help, but they don’t always address what is contributing to the problem in the first place.

Before deciding what to change, it is worth taking a step back and asking a different question.

If registration, retention and participation are outcomes, what is influencing them?

For example, if an organization is experiencing low registration, the immediate question might be, “How do we improve our registration numbers?” But there may be other questions worth asking. What are people experiencing when they participate? What are they saying about the program? What might influence someone to register, return, or look elsewhere?

Outcomes don’t happen in isolation. They are influenced by the experiences people have and the environments in which those experiences take place.

The Participant Experience System provides a way to look at these connections and consider how the different parts of a program contribute to the experiences participants have.

Understanding the Flow of the Participant Experience System

At the centre of the Participant Experience System is the participant’s experience. The way a program is designed influences how it is delivered. Delivery shapes what participants experience, and those experiences contribute to the outcomes we see.

The forward flow looks like this:

Design → Delivery → Experience → Outcome

Each stage has a different role.

  • Design is how we plan and structure the program, including the opportunities, activities, environment and intended experience.
  • Delivery is how that plan is brought to life through the actions, decisions and interactions of the people involved.
  • Experience is how participants perceive and respond to what takes place. This may be different from what the organization intended.
  • Outcome is what we see as a result, such as registration, attendance, retention, participation or other measures of success.

Looking Backward Through the System

This flow helps us understand how a program is intended to work. But the system can also help us look at things from the other direction.

When an outcome isn’t what we hoped for, we can work backward to better understand what may have contributed to it:

Outcome → Experience → Delivery → Design

Let’s return to the example of a club experiencing low retention.

The outcome tells us that fewer participants are returning. It doesn’t tell us why.

We can start by looking at the experiences participants have had. Have they felt welcome? Have they enjoyed participating? Do they feel they are learning and improving? Are there barriers making it difficult to continue?

From there, we can look at how the program was delivered. What interactions, decisions or situations may have influenced those experiences?

Finally, we can consider the original design. Did the program provide the opportunities and environment we intended? Were there aspects of the structure or planning that contributed to what participants experienced?

By looking at each stage, we can investigate what may have contributed to the outcome before deciding what needs to change.

The stages can help us ask different questions:

  • Outcome: What happened?
  • Experience: How did participants perceive and respond to what happened?
  • Delivery: What actions and interactions contributed to that experience?
  • Design: What decisions and structures shaped the delivery?

The stages are connected. Design influences delivery, delivery influences experience, and experiences contribute to outcomes. We can then use what we learn to inform future decisions and adjust the design where needed.

This is not a one-way process. It is a cycle of planning, delivering, learning and adapting.

The Five Drivers of Participation

While the four stages help us understand how the system works, the Five Drivers of Participation help us consider what may be influencing the experiences participants have.

They provide different perspectives through which we can look at a program and the people involved.

Play and Enjoyment

Participants are more likely to continue when taking part is enjoyable and rewarding. This doesn’t mean every moment needs to be fun or easy. It means there should be opportunities for enjoyment, exploration and positive engagement.

Perceived Competence and Progression

Participants need opportunities to feel capable and recognize that they are learning or improving. Feeling overwhelmed, overlooked or unable to keep up can make participation less rewarding.

Belonging and Connection

Feeling accepted, valued and connected to others can make a meaningful difference to someone’s experience. Relationships with teammates, coaches, instructors and other participants can become an important reason to return.

Accessibility and Adaptability

Programs need to fit the realities of people’s lives. Time, cost, location, ability, scheduling and other circumstances can all influence whether someone is able to participate and continue.

Learning-Focused Environments

Participants benefit from environments where learning is encouraged and mistakes are treated as part of the process. This depends not only on individual coaches or instructors, but also on the attitudes and practices supported throughout the program.

For example, an organization may notice that attendance at practices is becoming inconsistent. Conversations with participants might reveal that school, work and other commitments are making it difficult to attend regularly.

In this situation, the issue may have little to do with enjoyment, competence or belonging. Accessibility and Adaptability may provide a more useful perspective to explore.

The drivers can also influence one another. For example, changing a practice schedule might make a program more accessible, but it could also affect the social connections participants develop. This is why it’s useful to consider the wider experience rather than looking at each driver in isolation.

The drivers aren’t separate stages of the system. They are ways of understanding the experiences taking place throughout it.

Experiences Create Patterns

A participant’s experience is shaped by more than one practice, competition or interaction. Over time, everyday moments contribute to how someone feels about being involved.

Repeated interactions, small successes, frustrations and opportunities to connect all play a part in shaping expectations. Over time, participants develop a sense of whether they feel comfortable, capable, included and interested in continuing.

Sometimes these experiences build gradually. A participant may begin to feel less connected to the group, become frustrated with their progress, or find that attending is becoming more difficult. Individually, these moments might not seem significant. Together, they can influence how someone views their involvement.

However, not every decision is the result of a gradual build-up. A single significant experience can be enough to change someone’s perception or influence their decision to leave.

In other cases, what appears to be an isolated incident may be connected to a longer pattern that has gone unnoticed.

The signals an organization sends through its planning, decisions and interactions are interpreted by participants through their own experiences. Over time, these experiences contribute to the impression they form of the program.

Understanding both the individual moments and the broader pattern can help us get a clearer picture of what participation actually feels like.

Not All Experiences Carry Equal Weight

Although everyday experiences contribute to the overall pattern, not every moment is remembered in the same way.

Some experiences are relatively ordinary. They become part of what a participant comes to expect from a program. Others stand out and can have a much stronger influence on how an interaction is remembered.

A meaningful achievement, an unexpected moment of connection, an experience of embarrassment, or an interaction that leaves someone feeling excluded can stay with a participant long after it has happened.

In The Power of Moments, Chip and Dan Heath explore how particularly significant moments and the way an experience ends can influence how people remember it. People may remember the moments that stand out, along with the final impression of an interaction, more strongly than the ordinary experiences surrounding them.

This is worth considering when we plan and deliver programs.

Think about the end of a practice. A participant may have enjoyed most of the session, but an uncomfortable final interaction with a coach or teammate could influence the impression they take away. On the other hand, a moment of recognition or connection could leave someone feeling valued and encouraged.

This doesn’t mean that one memorable moment can replace consistent delivery, or that every practice needs a spectacular finish. The everyday environment still matters. It provides the foundation within which these more significant moments take place.

It does mean that we should pay attention to the moments participants are likely to remember and consider how they leave an interaction. What happens throughout an experience matters, but so can the moments that stand out and the impression left at the end.

Patterns Become Information

The experiences participants have can provide useful information about how a program is working.

Participants may provide information through direct feedback. We can also learn from attendance patterns, changes in engagement, conversations with parents and observations from coaches or instructors.

For example, a parent might express frustration because they feel their child is not being treated fairly and has decided not to return.

This gives us somewhere to start, but it doesn’t necessarily tell us what needs to change.

What did the participant feel was unfair? Did they feel they weren’t getting as much playing time as others? Was it related to how teams were selected, how feedback was given, or how they were included in activities? When did this begin, and has it happened more than once?

These questions help us move beyond the initial complaint and understand more about the experience behind it.

The feedback might reveal an issue with how a coach delivers the program, a gap in the original design, or a difference between what the organization intended and what the participant actually experienced.

The important part is not to jump to a conclusion. It is to use the information available to ask better questions.

Information Helps Us Improve the System

Once we have a better understanding of what participants are experiencing, we can consider what adjustments might help.

Returning to the example of a participant who feels unfairly treated, we might explore the Belonging and Connection driver. Does the participant feel accepted and valued by the group? Are there situations where they feel overlooked or disadvantaged?

The answers may point toward changes in how activities are organized, how playing time is managed, or how coaches and instructors are supported and trained.

We may need to adjust how the program is delivered, or we may need to revisit the original design.
The important thing is that the response is connected to what we have learned, rather than simply introducing another quick fix.

Recognizing Concerns Earlier

We can also use the drivers to look for signs that an experience may not be working as intended before it becomes a larger concern.

For example, if participants are becoming less engaged, having difficulty connecting with others, or expressing frustration with their progress, these observations may give us an opportunity to learn more and make adjustments earlier.

Not every concern can be identified or resolved before someone decides to leave. A participant may have one particularly negative experience and feel unable to return. That experience still provides information that may help an organization understand what happened and reduce the likelihood of similar situations in the future.

If several participants leave after similar experiences, we may begin to see a pattern. Even when the incidents appear unrelated, there may be common factors in the way the program is designed or delivered.

When organizations pay attention to these experiences, they have more opportunities to learn, make adjustments and improve.

An Evolving System

The difference between a quick fix and taking a Participant Experience System approach is not that one involves making changes and the other doesn’t. Both may require adjustments.

What matters is how we approach those changes.

Rather than responding only to an outcome, we can look at the experiences that may have contributed to it, consider how the program was designed and delivered, and use what we learn to guide future decisions.

The system gives us a way to connect these pieces. It also gives us room to adapt as participants, programs and the environments around them change.

As we continue through this series, we’ll take a closer look at the four stages of the Participant Experience System, the Five Drivers of Participation, and how these ideas can be applied in different sport, recreation and movement environments.

Research and Influences

This system is informed by participation research, coaching science, systems thinking, game-based learning, and athlete development literature, including concepts explored through Sport for Life, LTAD models, and youth sport participation studies.

Participant Experience System Note

The Participant Experience System brings together ideas from sport and exercise science literature, participation research, game-based learning, and systems thinking. It is shaped by my experience in sport and recreation settings and applied as a practical system to design, deliver, and evaluate participant experiences.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *